“Susceptibility to Influenza”

If you live in the Northern Hemisphere you may have found that your laboratory was swamped by incoming influenza tests this season?

You would not be alone.

Influenza is an unpredictable beast. In my own neck of the woods, New Zealand, the 2015 season was busier than usual, the 2016 season was almost non-existent, and the 2017 season was very average.

Nobody knows what will happen with influenza during 2018.. (Note that as NZ is in the Southern Hemisphere, our winter is June, July , August, right in the middle of the year).

Often you will see Influenza “experts” on TV making predictions about how severe the forthcoming influenza season will be. However such predictions come with huge pinches of salt. You might well be better off predicting the stock market…

The truth is that we don’t really know how bad the forthcoming influenza season is going to be, whether you are an expert or just an interested bystander.

And as a result we have no idea how much each influenza season is going to cost a diagnostic laboratory that performs influenza testing.

Let’s say a bog standard Influenza/RSV PCR costs approximately $30. In a quiet season 1000 tests might get performed in a medium sized hospital. However in a busy season 5000 tests might be required, with an excess cost of $120000. This would of course cause the laboratory manager some sleepless nights!

I am glad I am not a laboratory manager..

And then there might be an influenza pandemic…

The same goes for Public Health Laboratories. The numbers of samples coming in for antigenic sub-typing will be closely related to the severity of the influenza season.

Contracts that laboratory providers have with healthcare funders need to take this unpredictability into account. Some sort of clause like “The diagnostic laboratory will perform up to X Influenza PCRs during the Influenza season. If this number is exceeded, further funding will be negotiated”. Unfortunately this is often not the case. Often laboratory providers will be so desperate to get the contract signed and sealed that they will accept these risks, and manage such problems reactively.

From a financial point of view, microbiology laboratories are very susceptible to influenza test volumes, just like they are susceptible to emerging diseases and MDROs, cohorts where “unexpected testing” may need to take place.

There will of course be some laboratories who are reimbursed per test performed (fee for service). Those places of course would be hoping for a pandemic every year!, but such laboratories/funding arrangements are getting less and less common. The funders are not daft!

I hope for a quiet influenza season this year, and that is nothing to do with my personal risk! (I look forward to receiving the quadrivalent vaccine in the next couple of months).


7 thoughts on ““Susceptibility to Influenza”

  1. You make alot of very good points. What might be useful is a reliable near patient test with good positive and negative predictive value for the patient having clinical influenza. Even better if that was funded by service users themselves with the lab receiving a fixed fee for overseeing quality control of kits and advice on interpretation when needed

    1. Yes, quite a few GP surgeries in NZ looking at User Pays rapid PCR test on Genexpert. The turnaround time for this on their new Xpress assays is down to 35 minutes!

  2. Maybe we should consider the possibility of rapid elisa.. Immunochromatography for example.. Very quick, very cheap, easy to perform and with sensitivity/specificity over 90%…

    1. I think the sensitivity of 90% on influenza immunochromatography might still be a bit optimistic. But would be a viable option if correct!

  3. Influenza has been prevented by black elderberry extract which is antiviral and boosts cytokines. I am a microbiologist and I stand by this as it is very effective at reducing flu symptoms. No diagnostic flu tests required, most people I talked with just got better including myself. I am 49 years and I never get the flu shot and I was never susceptible to the flu either, especially, with the recent epidemic of flu cases. Elderberry extract is so popular, it was “flying” off the shelves and health food stores could not keep it in stock fast enough during height of flu season.

  4. It is no excuse, not to get vaccinated. It is a choice and I believe it is only supporting a multi billion dollar industry which I don’t believe in. Believe me, I have worked in this industry for many years. Why keep people from knowing the truth about vaccines? What are we not telling them that they should know?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *